Choosing a legal marketing agency is easier when every proposal is assessed against the same commercial, technical and compliance-related questions. This guide provides a solicitor-focused RFP structure, interview checklist, weighted scorecard and recurring review process for comparing agencies without relying on unverified promises about rankings, enquiries or case outcomes.
Overview
A legal marketing agency may offer solicitor SEO, paid search, law firm website design, legal landing pages, content, local SEO or lead generation. Those services can be valuable, but different providers often define success differently. One may report impressions and form submissions; another may focus on qualified consultations, matter value or signed instructions. A fair comparison starts by defining what your firm needs before reviewing proposals.
Begin with a short procurement brief covering:
- The practice areas and locations to prioritise, such as family law, conveyancing, personal injury, employment or immigration.
- The commercial objective: more enquiries, better-qualified enquiries, improved visibility, reduced dependence on paid leads or a clearer intake process.
- The current baseline, including website traffic, enquiry volume, response times, consultation bookings and matters opened where those figures are available.
- The internal resources available for approvals, content, technical access and lead follow-up.
- The proposed starting term, review points and decision-makers.
Do not ask agencies to guarantee a fixed number of legal leads or search positions. Instead, ask what activities they will carry out, which assumptions their forecast uses, how results will be measured and how quickly the firm can identify poor lead quality or wasted spend.
What to track
1. Practice-area experience
Relevant experience should mean more than having worked with another professional services business. Ask for examples of work involving the practice areas, locations and client journeys that resemble yours. A campaign for conveyancing leads may require a different landing page and qualification process from one for family law or employment advice.
Ask each provider to explain how it would handle sensitive claims, testimonials, case studies, outcome descriptions and calls to action. The firm remains responsible for reviewing published material and should consider its professional obligations, applicable advertising expectations and data protection requirements before approval. Treat “compliant” as a process to demonstrate, not a label to accept without evidence.
2. Lead definitions and measurement
Put the word “lead” in writing. It might mean a completed form, a telephone call, a booked consultation, a prospective client who meets an initial matter criterion or a person who eventually instructs the firm. These are different stages and should not be reported as if they were interchangeable.
Ask for a proposed measurement path from source to outcome:
- First visit or referral source.
- Enquiry submission or tracked call.
- Contact made and initial qualification.
- Consultation booked or declined.
- Matter opened, where the firm chooses to share that information.
Confirm how duplicate, spam, irrelevant, out-of-area and previously known enquiries will be treated. For a useful background framework, see How to Track Solicitor Lead Sources and Legal Lead Qualification for Solicitors.
3. Methods and account access
For SEO, ask how the agency researches topics, maps pages to search intent, handles technical issues, refreshes existing content and reports on local visibility. For paid campaigns, ask about keyword selection, negative keywords, landing pages, budget controls, call tracking and search-term reviews. You can compare this with the practical considerations in Google Ads for Solicitors.
Require the firm to retain administrative ownership, or at least dependable access, to its domain, website, analytics, tag manager, advertising accounts, Google Business Profile and call-tracking data. The proposal should state who creates each account and what happens at termination.
4. Reporting, data and content quality
Request a sample monthly report. It should distinguish activity from outcomes and show the period covered, sources, spend where relevant, conversion definitions, lead quality and actions for the next period. Reports should be accessible to the firm rather than available only through a presentation.
Ask where enquiry data is stored, who can access it, how long it is retained and how data is transferred to the firm. Review consent language, cookies, tracking technologies and form handling with the appropriate internal or external adviser. The GDPR for Law Firm Websites workflow can support this review.
5. Fees, ownership and contract terms
Separate one-off work, recurring fees, advertising spend, software charges, content production and third-party costs. Ask whether unused hours roll forward, how additional work is approved and whether fees change when the campaign expands.
The agreement should address ownership of copy, designs, landing pages, tracking configurations, campaign history, data and accounts. It should also explain notice periods, handover support, export formats, outstanding invoices, access removal and what happens to live campaigns after termination. A lower fee is not necessarily better value if the firm cannot retain its assets or understand the work completed.
Example RFP questions
- What would you prioritise in the first 30, 60 and 90 days, and what would you need from the firm?
- How do you define a qualified legal enquiry for each proposed practice area?
- Which results are historical examples, which are forecasts and which depend on assumptions?
- Who performs the work, and who reviews legal content before publication?
- Which accounts and assets will remain under the firm’s control?
- How will the firm identify poor lead quality, tracking failures or wasted advertising spend?
- Can you provide two relevant references and explain the scope of each engagement?
Cadence and checkpoints
Use a simple weighted scorecard rather than choosing the most persuasive presentation. Score each provider from 1 to 5, where 1 means weak or unsubstantiated and 5 means clear, relevant and evidenced. Apply the following suggested weights, adjusting them to fit the firm:
| Criterion | Suggested weight | What a strong answer includes |
|---|---|---|
| Practice-area understanding | 20% | Relevant examples, realistic client journeys and careful treatment of sensitive claims |
| Measurement and lead quality | 20% | Agreed definitions, source attribution and a route from enquiry to outcome |
| Method and delivery team | 15% | Specific tasks, named responsibilities and a practical implementation sequence |
| Reporting and transparency | 15% | Live access, useful reports and clear explanations of limitations |
| Data and compliance process | 10% | Documented handling, approval points and sensible access controls |
| Commercial terms and ownership | 10% | Transparent costs, fair exit terms and firm control of accounts and assets |
| References and communication | 10% | Relevant references, responsive communication and defined escalation routes |
Run the evaluation in stages. First, issue the same RFP and provide the same baseline information. Second, score written responses independently before holding interviews. Third, ask shortlisted providers to walk through one proposed campaign or landing page, making clear that the exercise is illustrative rather than a request for unpaid strategic work. Finally, check references and review the contract before making a decision.
During the engagement, hold a short monthly operational review and a deeper quarterly review. Compare planned work with completed work, reported enquiries with qualified enquiries, and marketing activity with the firm’s capacity to respond. A lead-generation campaign cannot be evaluated properly if calls are missed, forms are not routed or outcomes are never recorded.
How to interpret changes
A rise in website traffic or form submissions is not automatically an improvement. Examine changes by source, practice area, location, device, landing page and qualification status. A fall in enquiries may reflect seasonality, a tracking problem, a budget change, a website release or a deliberate reduction in irrelevant traffic.
Use a short change log for each reporting period. Record what changed, when it changed, who approved it and what outcome is expected. Then allow enough time for the relevant channel to produce a meaningful signal before making several changes at once. If performance weakens, test the basic chain in order: tracking, page availability, enquiry routing, response time, targeting, message and qualification criteria.
For website-focused work, combine agency reports with an internal conversion review using the Law Firm Website Conversion Audit. For search-led activity, use the Law Firm SEO Content Refresh Workflow to distinguish content maintenance from a complete strategy change.
When to revisit
Revisit the scorecard monthly for delivery issues and quarterly for commercial performance. At each quarterly checkpoint, compare the original objectives with actual qualified enquiries, intake capacity, practice-area priorities, spend, rankings or visibility where relevant, and matters opened where the firm can measure them responsibly.
Repeat formal due diligence before renewing, expanding into another practice area or increasing advertising spend. Also review the arrangement when the agency changes personnel, reporting tools, subcontractors, data processes or contract terms. Refresh the RFP language when platform features, advertising expectations, privacy requirements or professional guidance change.
Before the next review, complete this action list:
- Export current reports and confirm that the firm can access every relevant account.
- Reconcile reported leads with the firm’s CRM, call records or enquiry log.
- Mark each lead as relevant, duplicate, unreachable, unsuitable, booked or converted where possible.
- Record the three most material changes since the previous review.
- Score delivery against the agreed criteria and request evidence for any disputed result.
- Agree only a small number of next actions, each with an owner and review date.
This recurring process keeps solicitor marketing decisions tied to client fit, operational capacity and measurable business outcomes. It also gives the firm a clear basis for improving the relationship, renegotiating its scope or running a new comparison when the evidence no longer supports the current arrangement.